The business case for ensuring you are a genuine Tenant DoctorTM and not a deemed employee-like contractor

“The absolute worst case that you could be in is to earn all of your income as an employee working for someone else.”

Greg Kaplan, chairman on think tank e61

Source:Wealth tax: Australian Financial Review, 25th July 2025 

The Tenant Doctor ModelTM is a legal and operational structure used in general medical practices across Australia to address payroll tax, compliance, risk management, and revenue efficiency. The approach separates the medical business (practitioner) from the service entity (infrastructure provider).

The Great GP Emancipation: Everyone is better off especially practitioners and patients! 

A key competitive advantage for recruitment, retention, and business viability is that you aren’t forced to require all doctors to bulk bill, set fixed fees, or pay additional payroll tax or superannuation on earnings from privately billed patients. The Tenant Doctor ModelTM offers greater flexibility and avoids administratively complex, high-fraud, and tax-risk individual banking arrangements, benefiting both doctors, their practices, and patients.

If you do not like reading…..

Watch our national Tenant Doctor Model for the Royal Australian College of General Practice: May 2025 Practice Owners Conference. How to set up a tax-compliant Tenant Doctor Model that is payroll tax and employer superannuation guarantee free and tax tested. 

Key Concepts

Tenant Doctor Arrangement: Doctors are independent practitioners who rent rooms or services from a service entity. They run their own businesses, usually with their own ABNs, websites, and advertising, and pay service fees for back-office support, staff, and premises rather than being employees or contractors of the medical centre.

Service Entity: Owns the infrastructure (premises, equipment, reception, admin) and provides management support services to practitioners for a transparent, pre-agreed fee.

Quistclose Account: A legally compliant Quistclose account used to collect doctor billings, ensuring transparency, separation of funds, and correct allocation per service agreements.

Governance and Documentation: Strict, annually updated service agreements and clear, separate bookkeeping are essential. Legal documents must specify the arrangement, how funds are handled, banking details, and who receives the banked money.

Central Principle: The core reason to establish a service entity is risk separation, so that no doctor is liable for another’s malpractice or debt (e.g. Medicare shared debt), NOT primarily for tax savings. From the outset, if your lawyer and accountant cannot or did not explain this to you when you had set up your practice, then you may have a significant problem. 

Critical Features and Benefits

Compliance: Properly-prepared and signed service agreements, transparent bank reconciled to the cent (including surcharges) banking, and accurate fee calculations help avoid payroll tax, superannuation obligations, and Fair Work risks.

Auditing and Risk: Audit risk is reduced if all evidence (websites, emails, invoices, financials) aligns with the tenant doctor structure. If the arrangement is not genuine or not supported by correct contracts, authorities may deem doctors as employees, triggering payroll tax and other liabilities.

Financial Transparency: Service fee calculations and payments must match contractual agreements. Independent, itemised invoices and accurate accounting are key; mismatched financial statements or improper banking arrangements are red flags.

Advertising and Operations: Each doctor should maintain their own brand presence (website, marketing) to reinforce business separation. The service entity should market as a facility host, not as the provider of patient care.

Flexible, Fair Fees: Service fees may be adjusted based on utilisation, complexity (e.g., higher admin fee for care plans), or efficiency, using modern calculators integrated with the practice’s financial systems.

Common Pitfalls

Mislabelling: Describing doctors as “contractors” or “employees,” commingling finances, single-entity branding, or lack of clear, annualised documentation puts the practice at risk.

Improper Banking: Simply creating a separate bank account is not sufficient; there must be a legally documented and operationally correct process governing how money flows, who owns the money, and when it is distributed.

Legacy Issues: Many practices unintentionally adopted models inspired by large corporates (with actual employees or contractor setups), leading to confusion, precedent court cases, and increased scrutiny from tax authorities.

Latest Tax and Legal Developments: Recent court cases and ATO/State Revenue actions have clarified that if a practice appears to be a single business (based on how it banks, advertises, or invoices), payroll tax obligations likely apply, even if the contract states otherwise.

Automated data matching, new mandatory accountant reporting, and much larger ATO enforcement budgets have rapidly increased compliance requirements.

Uber Case: A recent important judgment states that the “substance” of business relationships, how things actually operate, is more important than what a contract claims, increasing risk for practices that do not align documentation and real world operation. 

Regardless of your well written service agreements how you govern and run your practice matters. The devil is in the detail, many legal contracts may fall seen as a “sham” arrangements. You have to prove your arrangements with third party evidence, see Uber Payroll Tax Appeal (NSW) decision, 2025. This precedent decision will have a significant impact on both State and Federal tax and employment laws. 

Third-party evidence (lawyers, accountants and practices must check)

How you register both your practitioners and yourself across publicly verifiable platforms—such as your website, tax filings, PRODA, Healthcare Identifier (Seed Organisation), and AHPRA (e.g. provider annual declaration must state they are in a cost sharing arrangement) can significantly impact your professional standing and compliance obligations. 

Getting these registrations right ensures that your credentials and practice details are accurately visible and data match to the public, government agencies, and other healthcare providers. For example, using the correct personal and organisational information during PRODA registration is critical for identity verification and system access. Likewise, maintaining up-to-date practitioner records with AHPRA and submitting accurate annual declarations is essential for compliance and transparency. For further information, please refer to the detailed guidance provided in the webinar referenced above.

Side Bar: GP Practice Accreditation we appreciate that the Royal Australian College of general practice is seeking consultation to clarify the role of the service entities (which the RACGP has recognised the role of service entities since the 1978 Phillips case Federal Court case decision) that are genuine Tenant Doctor (service entity) arrangements. Currently this affects Healthcare Identifier and PRODA registration. Contact us for more information.

Best Practice Steps

Review All Arrangements: Ensure your business model, contracts, banking, advertising, and communications align with the tenant doctor model.

Get Professional Help: Have qualified lawyers and accountants (with explicit tenant doctor model experience) review all documents and systems annually.

Educate All Parties: Owners, doctors, and staff must understand the structure and be consistent in language and workflow.

Update Regularly: Tax rulings and laws are constantly evolving; proactive annual updates help ensure compliance.

Be Able to Prove It: Maintain audit trails, consistent financials, signed agreements, and properly segregated accounts. 

Compliance is Affordable: Finally you can go back to see patients and not more lawyers and accountants. The unique cloud program the Doctors Pay (Service Fee) Calculator can save your practice so you can continue you to eat well and sleep well.  

For many of our savvy clients and practitioners, the complete process, including digitally encrypted, legally prepared up to date service agreements integrated with Xero, bank-reconciled and tax-compliant invoices, as well as BAS and tax extract summaries, is available for less than $70 per practitioner per month (based on a group of 5–10 practitioners). Initial setup fee not included. 

This represents a significant saving when compared to the potential additional cost of up to $1,000 per month per full-time equivalent practitioner for employment-related expenses such as payroll tax, 12% superannuation, Fair Work leave entitlements, and the time-consuming process of completing complex payroll tax forms, particularly if you are bulk billing in an effort to secure discounts, which may ultimately render your entire practice unviable, see Fact Check: Benchmarking the 2025 $8.5 bn Strengthening Medicare (“Financial Suicide”) Package.

Conclusion

The Tenant Doctor Model, if set up and managed correctly, offers strong legal and financial protection for medical practices, minimises payroll tax risk, streamlines finances, and enhances long-term practice value and succession planning. 

However, insufficient understanding, poor implementation, or reliance on unqualified templated advice exposes practices to substantial cash flow problems, fraud, error, tax, super, and Fair Work liabilities.

If your lawyers, accountants or advisers don’t fully understand the rules and haven’t been able to explain them clearly to you and what to do next (except wait for another court case), which is why you’re still confused, we can certainly work with your regular accountant and get you over the line.

The rules have always been clear, in fact they have been since 1978! As a Supreme Court judge once said to a GP “Ignorance of the law is no excuse”.  We are all running out of time and excuses. 

For more insights visit our blog.

About me: David Dahm BA (Acc.), CA., FCPA, CTA, FFin, CPM, FAAPM, FAIM, FGLF.

Chartered Accountant, Chartered Tax Adviser, Registered Tax Agent, Former AGPAL Surveyor 10 years of service

David Dahm is CEO and founder of the national medical and healthcare chartered accounting firm Health and Life and global Founder and CEO of the not for profit project the International Healthcare Standards and Ethics Board (www.ihseb.org)

After a serious work related car accident in 1989, and nine operations later I continue to be a patient and provider advocate. I enter my third decade as a national Chartered Accountant for Medical and Healthcare practices in Australia. I am a former 10-year Australian General Practice Accreditation surveyor. I come from a medico family. I have served on the AAPM national Board and was the inaugural national Chair of the Certified Practice Manager CPM post nominal. I continue to provide accounting tax and practice management advice to many practices all over Australia.

You know who you are and I thank you for this real honour and privilege to serve you and your community through you. Note, I am not a lawyer please seek appropriate legal and accounting advice. This information is for general information and discussion only.


Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

Recommended Posts

No comment yet, add your voice below!


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *